Choi, Jaemin (2010-05). Theatricality, Cheap Print, and the Historiography of the English Civil War. Doctoral Dissertation. Thesis uri icon

abstract

  • Until recent years, the historical moment of Charles II's return to England was universally accepted as a clear marker of the end of "the Cavalier winter," a welcome victory over theater-hating Puritans. To verify this historical view, literary historians have often glorified the role of King Charles II in the history of the "revival" of drama during the Restoration, whereas they tend to consider the Long Parliament's 1642 closing of the theaters as a decisive manifestation of Puritans' antitheatricalism. This historical perspective based upon what is often known as "the rupture model" has obscured the vibrant development of dramatic forms during the English civil wars and the ways in which the revolutionary energy exploded during this period continued to influence in the Restoration the deployment of dramatic forms and imagination across various social groups. By focusing on the generic development of drama and theatricality during the English civil wars, my dissertation challenges the conventional historiography of the English civil war literature, which has been overemphasizing the discontinuity between the English civil war and the periods before and after it. The first chapter shows how the theatrical energy displaced from traditional cultural domains energized an emerging cheap print market and contributed to the invention of new dramatic forms such as playlets and newsbooks. The second chapter questions the conventional association of Puritanism and antitheatricalism by rehistoricizing antitheatrical writers and their pamphlets and by highlighting the dramatic impulses at work in Puritan iconoclasm during the English civil wars. The final chapter offers the Restoration Milton as a case study to illustrate how the proposed historical perspective replacing "the rupture model" better explains not only the politics of Milton's Paradise Lost but also of Restoration drama.
  • Until recent years, the historical moment of Charles II's return to England was

    universally accepted as a clear marker of the end of "the Cavalier winter," a welcome

    victory over theater-hating Puritans. To verify this historical view, literary historians

    have often glorified the role of King Charles II in the history of the "revival" of drama

    during the Restoration, whereas they tend to consider the Long Parliament's 1642

    closing of the theaters as a decisive manifestation of Puritans' antitheatricalism. This

    historical perspective based upon what is often known as "the rupture model" has

    obscured the vibrant development of dramatic forms during the English civil wars and

    the ways in which the revolutionary energy exploded during this period continued to

    influence in the Restoration the deployment of dramatic forms and imagination across

    various social groups. By focusing on the generic development of drama and

    theatricality during the English civil wars, my dissertation challenges the conventional historiography of the English civil war literature, which has been overemphasizing the

    discontinuity between the English civil war and the periods before and after it.

    The first chapter shows how the theatrical energy displaced from traditional

    cultural domains energized an emerging cheap print market and contributed to the

    invention of new dramatic forms such as playlets and newsbooks. The second chapter

    questions the conventional association of Puritanism and antitheatricalism by rehistoricizing

    antitheatrical writers and their pamphlets and by highlighting the dramatic

    impulses at work in Puritan iconoclasm during the English civil wars. The final chapter

    offers the Restoration Milton as a case study to illustrate how the proposed historical

    perspective replacing "the rupture model" better explains not only the politics of

    Milton's Paradise Lost but also of Restoration drama.

publication date

  • May 2010