Decentralization: The Corridor Is the Problem, Not the Alcove. Academic Article uri icon


  • There is controversy today about whether decentralized intensive care unit (ICU) designs featuring alcoves and multiple sites for charting are effective. There are issues relating to travel distance, visibility of patients, visibility of staff colleagues, and communications among caregivers, along with concerns about safety risk. When these designs became possible and popular, many ICU designs moved away from the high-visibility circular, semicircular, or box-like shapes and began to feature units with more linear shapes and footprints similar to acute bed units. Critical care nurses on the new, linear units have expressed concerns. This theory and opinion article relies upon field observations in unrelated research studies and consulting engagements, along with material from the relevant literature. It leads to a challenging hypothesis that criticism of decentralized charting alcoves may be misplaced, and that the associated problem may stem from corridor design and unit size in contemporary ICU design. The authors conclude that reliable data from research investigations are needed to confirm the anecdotal reports of nurses. If problems are present in current facilities, organizations may wish to consider video monitoring, expanded responsibilities in the current buddy system, and use of greater information sharing during daily team huddles. New designs need to involve nurses and carefully consider these issues.

published proceedings

  • Crit Care Nurs Q

altmetric score

  • 1.5

author list (cited authors)

  • Hamilton, D. K., Swoboda, S. M., Lee, J., & Anderson, D. C.

citation count

  • 14

complete list of authors

  • Hamilton, D Kirk||Swoboda, Sandra M||Lee, Jin-Ting||Anderson, Diana C

publication date

  • January 2018