Ely, Brandon Lee (2008-08). Houston LDAR II network: design, operation, and performance analysis. Doctoral Dissertation. Thesis uri icon

abstract

  • The Houston LDAR II network is an array of twelve VHF time-of-arrival (TOA) sensors operated by Texas A&M University. The goals of the network are to conduct indepth studies of thunderstorm electrification and provide timely lightning threats to the Houston area. Before analyses are conducted using data from the Houston LDAR network, it is necessary to understand the LDAR network? s performance and limitations, such as the LDAR source detection efficiency, network range, and location accuracy. Initial results from the 31 October 2005 Mesoscale Convective System (MCS) timing error analysis revealed an RMS timing error for the Houston LDAR network of 90 ns for 6 sensor solutions. This gives a three-dimensional location accuracy of 1 km at a distance of 150 km and 100 m over the center of the network. Reanalysis with updated sensor positions decreased the RMS timing error to 75 ns. This decrease in RMS timing error increased the median three-dimensional location accuracy by ~100 m at a 100 km range. The network has been operated at both 70 MHz and 40 MHz. Model results of detection efficiency suggest that the change to 40 MHz yields an increase of 9 - 10 dB in network sensitivity. Analysis of VHF source power distributions shows a similar shift from that expected from the model. These results show that the 40 MHz LDAR network detects ~3.3 times more VHF sources than the 70 MHz network. The analysis of the usable network range for research purposes is currently set by rough guidelines of location accuracy and detection efficiency. For location accuracy, a 1 km limit allows storm analysis out to a range of more than 150 km. For the detection efficiency analysis, results based on source power distributions suggest a gradual fall off with range. Examining the change in VHF source density by range reveals different results. VHF source density remained fairly constant out to a range of 100 km at which point a significant fall off was observed. Based on these results the usable network range for the Houston network is 100 km.
  • The Houston LDAR II network is an array of twelve VHF time-of-arrival (TOA)

    sensors operated by Texas A&M University. The goals of the network are to conduct indepth

    studies of thunderstorm electrification and provide timely lightning threats to the

    Houston area. Before analyses are conducted using data from the Houston LDAR

    network, it is necessary to understand the LDAR network? s performance and limitations,

    such as the LDAR source detection efficiency, network range, and location accuracy.

    Initial results from the 31 October 2005 Mesoscale Convective System (MCS)

    timing error analysis revealed an RMS timing error for the Houston LDAR network of

    90 ns for 6 sensor solutions. This gives a three-dimensional location accuracy of 1 km at

    a distance of 150 km and 100 m over the center of the network. Reanalysis with updated

    sensor positions decreased the RMS timing error to 75 ns. This decrease in RMS timing

    error increased the median three-dimensional location accuracy by ~100 m at a 100 km

    range. The network has been operated at both 70 MHz and 40 MHz. Model results of

    detection efficiency suggest that the change to 40 MHz yields an increase of 9 - 10 dB in

    network sensitivity. Analysis of VHF source power distributions shows a similar shift

    from that expected from the model. These results show that the 40 MHz LDAR network

    detects ~3.3 times more VHF sources than the 70 MHz network.

    The analysis of the usable network range for research purposes is currently set by

    rough guidelines of location accuracy and detection efficiency. For location accuracy, a

    1 km limit allows storm analysis out to a range of more than 150 km. For the detection

    efficiency analysis, results based on source power distributions suggest a gradual fall off

    with range. Examining the change in VHF source density by range reveals different

    results. VHF source density remained fairly constant out to a range of 100 km at which

    point a significant fall off was observed. Based on these results the usable network

    range for the Houston network is 100 km.

publication date

  • August 2008