Slatton, Brittany C. (2009-08). Deep Frames, White Men's Discourse, and Black Female Bodies. Doctoral Dissertation. Thesis uri icon

abstract

  • In this qualitative study, I examine the persistent trend of black women as an
    excluded relationship partner for white men. Integral to understanding the exclusion of
    black women as relationship partners is the construction of black female bodies, by
    influential white men historically and contemporarily, as the abject opposite of
    hegemonic femininity, which holds "middle-class, heterosexual, [w]hite femininity" as
    the norm (Collins 2005:193). This construction essentially places black women outside
    the bounds of hegemonic femininity, beauty, sexuality, and womanhood. Using the
    theoretical concept deep frame, which is the "conceptual infrastructure of the mind"
    (Lakoff 2006a:12) and representative of one's commonsense world view, I argue that the
    ways in which influential white men have constructed black female bodies is a critical
    component of the raced, gendered, and classed deep frame of white men. This deep
    frame undergirds how many white men perceive, interpret, understand, emote, and
    engage in actions where black women are concerned. Hence in this study, I qualitatively
    examine, through analyzing and interpreting the in-depth online questionnaires of 134 white male respondents, how the deep frame of white men affects how they perceive
    black women and ultimately the relationships they seek with black women.
    The results of the study show that many white male respondents, despite most
    having very limited or no personal interactions with black women, viewed black women
    through the one-dimensional lens of the raced, gendered, and classed deep frame. Many
    respondents perceived black women as unattractive unless capable of a white normative
    standard, as possessing a negative "black" culture, and as possessing negative and
    "unfeminine" attributes that make them complicit in their own rejection. These findings
    show how the deep frame disciplines white men to view black women as "out of
    bounds" as legitimate relationship partners, and disciplines the types of relationships
    they seek with black women. The results of this study also reveal that the conceptual
    approach of deep frame rooted in an understanding of the power of influential white men
    to control and construct society provides a theoretical alternative to the outmoded
    interracial marriage theories of caste and exchange.

publication date

  • August 2009